Tag Archives: Recipes

This Is the Part When Someone Says, “Let Me Make You a Sandwich”

What a beautiful statement. Let me make you a sandwich.

I just listened to an episode of the Wiser Than Me podcast, hosted by Julia Louis Dreyfuss, in conversation with Patti LaBelle.

Patti’s sister, who died at 44, asked Patti to make her a fried egg sandwich the day before she died. Patti, just home from a tour – just, asked for a day to recover and then the sandwich – you know it would have been delicious! – would be made. Opportunity lost. Not throwing any shade because – obviously – no one knew that time had run out.

Apparently Patti LaBelle is a comfortable, happy, generous, capable cook and she is called upon to feed and nurture all those who know her. Lucky them.

Patti went on to talk about – and this has been documented in many notable forums – her guilt, regret and sadness about not making the sandwich. She was haunted by a sandwich not made. Understood.

Dilemma. Powerful.

Need I mention that a sandwich is the conflux of all things human? Of course not. Bread, the “staff” of life , holding/cradling/securing the necessary stuff, the essentials. And Patti cooks. She has authored countless cookbooks. Book covers hold/cradle/secure the necessary stuff, the essentials. Staff? She must have staff. The staff of life. To do what she does would require STAFF.

Dilemma. For me, if I ask you for a fried egg sandwich, it is the asking that matters. If you agree to make it, that is more than enough. The actual making? Not so much. Should we run out of time, for whatever reason – on to other things, sudden thunder storm, overflowing bathtub – it’s the sandwich thought that matters. Always.

MMSMINYC Takes the Reins

LEXINGTON CANDY SHOP – NYC

Hey there sandwich lovers.  It’s James (formerly known as Lisa’s Main Sandwich Man in NY), unmasked and guest blogging today.  Do you like eateries that have been around for over 100 years?  Of course you do.  I know a couple in NYC.  One is Barney Greengrass on the Upper West Side:

but that’s an appetizing post for another time.

The other is the Lexington Candy Shop on the Upper East Side:

Surprise! … it’s not a candy shop, though you can pick up some old favorites like Choward’s Scented Gum [see photo] at the checkout counter, where you pay (cash tips preferred left on the table).  So, if it’s not a candy shop, then what is it?  I guess it’s a diner, but it’s called a Luncheonette, which is fun to say – right?  This joint has the vintage look and vibe you’d expect from a 100-year-old institution.  Start with that classic corner entrance and neon sign.  Then add the soda fountain counter with the stainless-steel backdrop behind it, and finish up with those vinyl clad booths. 

On the menu there are throwbacks such as Frosteds, Malteds, Egg Creams, Fresh Orangeaid, Lime Rickeys, and Cinnamon Toast.  Plus, they serve the ever-rich Bassett’s Ice Cream from Philadelphia.

Except for the egg cream, I have not tried any of those things.  That’s because I can’t resist the TUNA MELT.

The Lex Candy Shop Tuna Melt is not a gut bomb.  Fries  are not included though it does come with a pickle spear.  Some may argue that the sandwich is a bit pricey, but the price includes the total old-world (time warp?) experience. 

The sandwich comes closed face by default, though you can request an open face version on toasted English Muffin.  You get a choice of cheeses and breads. I opt for cheddar cheese and rye bread. 

Let’s begin with the tuna, which is always fresh tasting and never fishy (so the scented gum is not necessary).  There is ample finely diced celery in the tuna, adding a nice crunchy texture and a refreshing taste.  Mayo is present, but only just enough.  And the nicely chewy rye has caraway seeds – not just on the crust, but throughout the bread – adding an additional flavor layer. 

I’m not sure how they toast the sandwich, but it’s not drenched in butter so it’s not greasy, and the toasting is enough to melt the cheese without heating up the fish.  The Lex Candy Shop Tuna Melt seems light enough that you could eat two … but you don’t … or maybe you do?

Where better to post about a Luncheonette but on The Lunch Encounter – you dig?

Goo Reuben

I will be in Omaha soon, a first visit to Nebraska, and understand that the Reuben sandwich might have originated there. There is no disputing the brilliance of the Reuben’s construction. Frankly, I cannot imagine the path to the Reuben but will take a stab at it.

Corned beef and rye begets

Corned beef on rye with cheese begets

Corned beef on rye with cheese and Russian dressing begets

Corned beef on rye with cheese and Russian dressing. And sauerkraut? Huh? Sauerkraut? No lie, sauerkraut is delicious but, I swear, someone had sauerkraut in excess (of course because…cabbage) and thought it could be hidden behind CORNED BEEF, RYE, CHEESE AND RUSSIAN DRESSING because, without a doubt, a GIANT Louis Vuitton bag could be hidden behind CORNED BEEF, RYE, CHEESE AND RUSSIAN DRESSING. The bag would be eaten – lock, stock and barrel – almost without notice, so yeah, let’s unload a mess o’ kraut while we’re at it. And the world pivoted on its axis.

Booeymonger – speaking of being unable to imagine a path, I cannot imagine the path to that name, Booeymonger. Must sleuth. The original Booeymonger – tiny, on a side-street, open very late, oh-so-intriguing to a wandering teen – had the Guruben on it’s menu, a sandwich name on par with the Teuben (a Reuben in a casing, sausage-style at Hot Doug’s in Chicago), as well as the Vegetarrorist at Cafe Clementine (so clever, so not-scary when it was conceived, funny, so funny, and now not, damnit!) Booeymonger, to this day, lists the Patty Hearst on its menu. How now, provolow? The Patty Hearst but no Guruben? What wokeness has got by me?

Happily Another Year – We’re Still Here!

This post ran Thanksgiving 2012. We are reprising it here at The Lunch Encounter in 2013 in celebration of a year for which to be thankful indeed. 

Watershed moment at The Lunch Encounter. A recipe.

Do we need any more recipes? No we do not. That said, I’m feeling strong about posting this one.

Last Thanksgiving I was thinking about the ubiquitous turkey-cranberry sauce-stuffing sandwich and had an aha moment.

Do you like that stuffing in the sandwich? I do not, although the taste is good. What we need here is my brilliant idea – Stuffing Bread! I’m so excited about this that I can’t shut up. Toss a turkey leg into a crowd and you will hit one of my victims. Poor thing had to listen to me gaggle on and on and on about my brilliant idea.

Last year Thanksgiving and the leftover turkey got away from me. Stuffing bread was back-burnered. This year however – woo hoo – we did it. I’m all puffed up like the Tom himself.

Tell you what, stuffing bread is brilliant. I think so anyhow. Here’s how to make it yourself.

Stuffing Bread

Makes 2 9×5-inch loaves

2 cups finely diced celery, about 4 ribs
2 cups finely diced yellow onion, about 1 large
3 tablespoons unsalted butter

(This picture is only enough for one loaf. You will need double of everything for the full recipe.)

Put the butter, onion and celery into a medium sauté pan and set over low heat. Stir to coat the vegetables evenly with butter, then let cook slowly until very soft, about 10 minutes. A little browning is okay, but watch that they don’t get dark.

1 quart unsalted turkey or chicken stock, 1/4 cup set aside

Add the stock to the vegetables, turn the heat to high and bring the stock to a boil. Let boil until the liquid has reduced to what looks like 2 cups. It need not be exact, but it must be 2 cups or less, not more. Remove from heat and pour into a liquid (glass pitcher style) measuring cup. Add cold water to make 2 cups, if needed. Let the mixture cool until it is tepid.

2 tablespoons minced fresh parsley
1 tablespoon minced fresh sage
1 tablespoon minced fresh thyme

Add the herbs to the stock mixture.

1 package active dry yeast (I like Hodgson Mill Fast Rise)
1 teaspoon sugar

Put the reserved 1/4 cup stock into a small bowl, add the yeast and sugar and stir until the yeast is completely wet. Set aside for 5 minutes.

5 cups all-purpose white flour
1 cup whole wheat flour

Put 4 cups white flour, 1 cup whole wheat flour, the stock mixture and the yeast mixture into the bowl of the standing mixer. Using the hook attachment, blend until a  dough begins to form. Add the remaining cup of flour and let it spin for a minute or so. The dough should be soft and not sticky.

This can all be done by hand, too, of course.

Water, as needed

If it is dry, add more water a couple tablespoons at a time.

1 tablespoon salt
Freshly ground pepper, black or white

As the dough is mixing, add salt and a generous grinding of pepper.

Knead the dough, by machine or by hand on a lightly floured surface, until it is smooth and elastic, adjusting with flour or water if necessary.

Butter a bowl, put the dough in it, cover with a tea towel and set in a warm place to rise for about an hour. It should double in size.

When it is twice its original size, punch the dough down. If you have time, cover it again and let it rise a second time. If not, turn it out onto a lightly floured surface and shape it into two loaves, pinching any seams together tightly.

Grease two 9×5-inch loaf pans and set the dough in them, seam side down. Cover with the tea towel and let the dough rise again until it is almost double.

Preheat the oven to 450 degrees F.

Bake the loaves in the center of the oven for 10 minutes. Reduce oven temperature to 350 degrees F and bake for about 30 more minutes. The bread should be nicely browned and sound hollow when you tap on the top.

 Let cool on a rack. Turn out and let cool completely before slicing.

Really tasty toast, too!

There. Hap hap happy. We dignified that bird.